Who Stands Between?
The Costa Mesa Question and the Priesthood Jesus Restored
A covenant look at the argument over women in the pulpit
·

This article is commentary on and criticism of a publicly posted video by Mike Winger concerning Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa. Watch the full video here: Mike Winger on Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa (YouTube).
The video and the sermon clips it contains are summarized and briefly quoted for the purposes of criticism, comment, and teaching, as fair use under 17 U.S.C. § 107. All rights in that material remain with its owners. Ten Words Press is not affiliated with Mike Winger, Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa, or any Calvary Chapel body, and none of them has reviewed or endorsed this article. Please watch the video in full and weigh it for yourself.
Before We BeginA Word to the Reader
If you were raised in a Calvary Chapel, you were taught by people who love Jesus and love the Bible. Nothing in this article is meant to take that from you. The two men at the center of this argument both love the Lord. I write as a brother to both, and I will tell you where I think each one is right.
I will ask one thing of you. Keep your Bible open beside you and check every verse. Do not take my word for anything. The believers in Berea were praised because they “examined the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so” (Acts 17:11). That is all I am asking.
One note on names. In the Hebrew Scriptures God has a personal Name, which is written Yahweh. Most English Bibles print it as “the LORD.” When a verse uses the Name, I will use it too.
Part OneWhat Happened at Costa Mesa
On November 1, 2026, Pastor Char Brodersen stood before Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa and read a statement. He is the lead pastor there, and the grandson of the founder, Chuck Smith. The church, he said, “believes and practices the ordination of both men and women to pastoral ministry.” He added that this was not a new practice. The church had been doing it for almost ten years.
Mike Winger answered with a video about ninety minutes long. Winger was ordained in Calvary Chapel and trained at the school of ministry in Costa Mesa. He loves that church family, and you can hear it. His case has three parts:
First, this reverses what Chuck Smith and Brian Brodersen taught from that pulpit for fifty years. Second, the change was made quietly over ten years and then announced as if nothing had changed. Third, the change is wrong according to the Bible, mainly Genesis 1 to 3 and 1st Timothy 2.
Winger is careful and kind in ways worth noticing. He says plainly that Brodersen is not denying the authority of Scripture. He corrects people who predict where the church will go next. He calls the Costa Mesa leaders his brothers. I want to treat both men the same way. So let us weigh what each one says by the text, and nothing else.
Part TwoWhere Mike Winger Is Right
He is right about the ten years. By the pastor’s own words, the church ordained women for a decade. Winger shows the church’s staff page, where the title “pastor” appears only under men, while the pulpit calls a woman on that same page a pastor. Many in the congregation, he says, did not know.
This matters no matter which side you take on women in ministry. The Ninth of the Ten Words, which most Bibles call the Ten Commandments, forbids false witness. A shepherd owes his flock the plain truth about what he believes and what he is doing. Paul held himself to that standard.
Even a true teaching should come in by the front door.
Winger is right about three more things. Pastor Brodersen argued that Paul would not have needed to tell Timothy something Timothy already knew, so the instruction must have been new and local. But Paul tells Timothy many things Timothy surely knew, such as the character an elder must have. That argument does not work.
He is right that we cannot build doctrine on guesses about the goddess Artemis and what her followers in Ephesus believed. That is background. A teaching that binds God’s people has to come from the text.
And he is right about the Seed. Pastor Brodersen said redemption was promised “not through a man, but through the seed of the woman.” But the Seed of the woman is a Man. He is Jesus.
So Winger found real weak spots in the other side’s case. But finding weak arguments on one side does not prove the other side. For that we have to open Genesis. Come and read it with me.
Part ThreeGenesis: Where “Rule” First Appears
Winger teaches that the husband’s authority over the wife was part of God’s design before sin, and that the fall only added conflict. He gives three reasons. Adam was made first. Adam named the animals and then named the woman. And the woman was made for the man.
Read the chapters in order and watch for one thing: where does one of them first rule the other?
In Genesis 1:26 to 28, God gives dominion. He gives it to “them,” and it is over the fish, the birds, and the animals. Neither one is placed over the other.
In Genesis 2:15, God puts the man in the garden “to serve it and to keep it.” Hold on to those two words. Later in the Bible the same two words describe the work of those who serve at God’s tabernacle (Numbers 3:7 to 8; 18:5 to 7). The garden was a holy place, and Adam was its priest.
Then God makes the woman as “a helper matching him.” Do not let the word “helper” fool you. The Bible uses the same word for Yahweh Himself when He helps Israel (Exodus 18:4; Psalm 33:20). It does not mean a lower rank. She was made from his side to stand beside him in that holy place.
Now look at the naming. When Adam names the animals, Genesis says he “called names” for them (2:19 to 20). When God brings the woman to him, that wording is missing. Adam says, “This is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh. She shall be called Woman, because she was taken out of Man.” After a long line of creatures that were not like him, he knows his own kind when he sees her. That is joy and recognition.
The naming words do come back. “And Adam called his wife’s name Eve” (Genesis 3:20). Notice where that verse sits. It comes after the fall, and after God has spoken judgment.
The same is true of the word “rule.” The first time the Bible says one of them will rule the other is Genesis 3:16. God says it while He is describing what sin has done. It sits in the same speech as the thorns, the sweat, the pain in childbirth, and the return to dust. We do not teach thorns as God’s good design. We should not teach this as His design either.
Winger answers with a comparison. Adam was already working the ground before the fall, and the fall added thorns. So, he says, the husband was already in authority, and the fall added strife. But look closely. The work is in the text before the fall. You can put your finger on it in Genesis 2:15. The husband’s rule is not there. It has to be read in.
One more detail. Winger reads “your desire shall be for your husband” as a desire to control him. That reading is recent. It was first argued in 1975, in an article by Susan Foh in the Westminster Theological Journal. The ancient Greek translation of the Old Testament, the one the apostles often quoted, says something gentler and sadder.
She turns toward him, and he answers by ruling her. God is describing a wound. He is not giving a command. And everything Jesus came to do is aimed at healing what the fall broke.
Part Four“For the Man” and “the Head”
Winger points out that Paul says the woman was created for the man (1st Corinthians 11:9). He is right. Paul does say it. But keep reading two more verses.
“Nevertheless, in the Lord.” With those words Paul tells us where believers stand now. And in that same chapter, women are praying and prophesying out loud when the church gathers (11:5). Paul gives direction on how they should do it. He never questions whether they may.
Winger’s deepest worry is for marriages, and I honor that. He does not want husbands and wives pulled away from what God commands. So let us look at what God commands in Ephesians 5.
Verse 21 says, “submitting to one another in the fear of Christ.” In the oldest copies of the letter, verse 22 has no verb of its own. It simply says, “wives, to your own husbands, as to the Lord.” It borrows its verb from the verse before. The word to wives is one part of a word spoken to everyone.
Now read what the husband is told. Love her. Give yourself up for her. Nourish her. Cherish her. He is called the head “as Christ is head of the church,” and Paul tells us at once what that means: Christ is “the Savior of the body,” who “gave Himself up for her” (5:23, 25).
Search the New Testament and you will not find one verse that commands a husband to rule his wife. And when Paul reaches for the strong Greek word that means to be master of a house, he gives it to the wives (1st Timothy 5:14). In Ephesians 5 the husband is given a cross to carry for her. A marriage built on that is safe.
Part Five1st Timothy 2
This is the passage the whole argument turns on, so I will start with the strongest point against my own reading. You deserve to see it first.
When Paul says, “I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man,” he gives his reason from Genesis. “For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and fell into transgression.” He does not mention a goddess or a local problem. Any honest reading has to deal with those two verses.
Here is how the letter itself answers. Paul tells us why he left Timothy in Ephesus: to stop certain people from teaching things they did not understand (1:3 to 7). He tells us who was being led away. Younger widows were going from house to house saying things they should not, and some had already turned aside (5:13 to 15). In his second letter he speaks of women who were “always learning and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth” (2nd Timothy 3:6 to 7). The trouble in Ephesus is written right there in the letters.
Now read verse 11. It is the only command in the passage: “Let a woman learn.” Whatever else Paul says here, he orders that she be taught.
Then verse 12. “I do not permit” is in the plain present tense. Paul is stating what he is doing in that place at that time.
And his reason fits. Eve was deceived. What is the cure for someone who has been deceived? Teaching. Until a person has learned, that person should not be the teacher. Paul uses Eve the same way in 2nd Corinthians 11:3, and there he is warning a whole church, men included.
Verse 15 finishes the thought: “she will be saved through the childbearing.” Paul has walked us from Genesis 2 into Genesis 3, and he ends where God’s word to the woman ends, with the promised Child who would crush the serpent.
I will be plain with you. This is a judgment about how to read a hard passage, and good people read it differently. Here is why I believe it is the right one.
The word translated “have authority” in verse 12 appears one time in the whole New Testament. Scholars argue about what it means. Winger spent years on it, and Pastor Brodersen reads it the opposite way. I do not think God hangs a permanent rule for half of His people on a word His apostles used once.
The Bible tells us to settle matters by two or three witnesses. So count the witnesses to what Paul and the first churches did:
Priscilla, with her husband, took Apollos aside and explained the way of God more accurately, and she did it in Ephesus (Acts 18:24 to 26). Phoebe was a deacon of the church at Cenchrea, and Paul trusted her to carry his letter to Rome (Romans 16:1 to 2). Junia is named with the apostles (Romans 16:7). Philip had four daughters who prophesied (Acts 21:9). And on the day the Holy Spirit was poured out, Peter stood up and told the crowd what these last days would look like.
That is five witnesses. When one verse seems to stand against five, the wise course is to ask whether we have read the one verse correctly.
Part SixWhat About Elders?
In the video, Winger plays an older sermon that quotes 1st Timothy 3:1 as “if a man desires the office of overseer.” Many English Bibles read that way. But the Greek word is “anyone.” If anyone desires it. Titus 1:6 uses the same word.
There is a fair point on the other side, and I will not hide it. The list that follows is written about men, and it includes “the husband of one wife.” But look eleven verses later. The very same phrase is used for deacons (3:12). And Paul calls Phoebe a deacon. So the phrase tells a married man to be faithful to his one wife. It cannot be a rule that shuts women out, or Phoebe could not have served.
Notice also what kind of leaders the New Testament describes. Peter tells elders not to lord it over the flock, but to be examples (1st Peter 5:1 to 3). And Jesus said something to His disciples that every church should hear again.
That verse brings us to the heart of the matter.
Part SevenWho Stands Between?
Winger’s strongest argument is about representation. He says we all fell in Adam, not in Eve. Jesus came as a man because men are the heads and the representatives. So men should hold the teaching office.
Take the facts one at a time, because they are true. Paul does say that in Adam all die (Romans 5:12 to 19; 1st Corinthians 15:22). God did give the command about the tree to Adam before the woman was made (Genesis 2:16 to 17). Adam stands at the head of the fallen human race. Jesus is called the last Adam, and He stands at the head of the redeemed.
But count how many representatives that is. It is two, in all of history. Each one stands for every human being, sons and daughters alike. Scripture never sets up a group of men to stand in for a group of women. When we move from “Jesus represents us” to “so men must hold the office,” we give a group of men a place the Bible gives to one Man only.
Paul says so himself, in the same chapter we just studied. It is seven verses before the verse everyone quotes.
To see why this matters so much, walk with me through the story of the priesthood. It will only take a minute, and you will need it.
At Mount Sinai, God made an offer to the whole nation, men and women together. “You shall be to Me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation” (Exodus 19:6). All of them heard His voice speak the Ten Words. But the people were afraid. They stepped back and asked Moses to stand between them and God (Exodus 20:18 to 19). Then they made the golden calf. After that, the priesthood was placed in one tribe, one family, and its sons (Exodus 32:26 to 29; Numbers 3:5 to 13). Aaron and his sons stood between the people and God’s presence, because the people could not stand there themselves. Hebrews tells us that arrangement was never meant to last. Its priests kept dying and had to be replaced (Hebrews 7:23).
Then Jesus died, and the veil of the temple was torn in two from top to bottom (Matthew 27:51). God opened the way Himself. Hebrews says the priesthood was changed. Jesus is a priest forever “according to the order of Melchizedek,” an older and higher priesthood that never depended on tribe or family line (Hebrews 7:11 to 17). And the offer God made at Sinai finally came true.
Peter wrote that to whole churches, to the men and the women. Every believer is a priest now. Every believer may come all the way in.
So here is the hard thing I have to say, and I say it with love. When we set apart one class of people to stand between God’s people and God’s word, and we say only men may be in it, we are rebuilding the order of Aaron after the veil has been torn. I believe that is what Winger is defending, though he does not mean to.
And Costa Mesa has not left it behind either. Pastor Brodersen’s statement says the change is based on “the priesthood of all believers.” That is a true and beautiful doctrine. But the church then uses it to ordain women into the same office, with the same title, on the same platform. If every believer is a priest, the answer is not a few more people in the special class. The answer is that the special class is finished.
One side guards the chair for sons. The other side offers it to daughters. Neither has asked whether the chair was still standing after the cross.
Calvary Chapel has long had a name for its way of leading a church. It is called the Moses model: one man over the congregation, answering to God. Winger mentions it, and he is glad to see it fading. I would only add that the name tells the truth. It is the request the people made at the foot of the mountain when they were afraid: you go near for us. Jesus has answered that fear. We may all come near now.
Part EightIs This a Small Matter?
Both men call this a secondary issue. I understand why. It is not the gospel itself, and no one is saved or lost by where they land on it.
But it is not small. The book of Hebrews treats the change of priesthood as one of the great results of the cross. Who may stand before God, and who must stand behind someone else, touches every believer in every pew. Even the Fifth of the Ten Words, when it names whom a child must honor, names two people: “your father and your mother.”
It is also not settled by history. Much of the weight in Winger’s video comes from this: Costa Mesa has left what Chuck Smith taught for fifty years. That is a fair complaint about how the change was made. It does not tell us whether the change is true. Winger himself says Chuck Smith was wrong to raise expectations about the date of the Lord’s return, and I think he is right to say so. A teaching is not true because a beloved church held it for a long time. It is not false because that church let it go.
Near the end, Winger gives his listeners a good rule: trust your eyes and read the text. I agree with all my heart. That is the very thing I have asked you to do in this article.
Part NineA Word to Each
To the leaders at Costa Mesa. Tell your people the whole truth about the last ten years, in plain words. Then finish what you started. The priesthood of all believers does not call for more pastors. It calls for a whole church of priests. Let the sons and daughters open the Scriptures as the Holy Spirit gives gifts, and let the elders shepherd as older brothers and sisters among the flock.
To those who are thinking of leaving. Ask yourself honestly why. If you are leaving because you were not told the truth for ten years, that is a serious reason. If you are leaving because a daughter of the King opened the Bible in the assembly, read Acts 2 once more before you go.
To Mike Winger. Thank you for insisting on honesty and for testing weak arguments. You have served the church by it. I only ask that you follow your own rule into Genesis 3, into 1st Timothy 2:5, and to the torn veil.
To you, the reader. You do not need anyone’s permission to come near to God. Jesus is your Mediator, and He is the only one you need. Open your Bible. The way in is open.
1. Read Genesis 1:26 through 3:20 in one sitting. Where does one person first rule another? What else is in that same speech?
2. Read 1st Timothy 2:1 to 15 as one passage. How does verse 5 shape the way you hear verse 12?
3. Read Exodus 19:6 beside 1st Peter 2:9. What did God offer at Sinai, and to whom does Peter say it now belongs?
4. Is there anyone you have been letting stand between you and God’s word? What would it look like to come near yourself this week?
Mike Winger, on Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa and the ordination of women: youtube.com/watch?v=A2P7OxcMKv0. Statements attributed to Mike Winger, Char Brodersen, and Brian Brodersen in this article are drawn from that video and the sermon clips shown in it. Scripture renderings are the author’s own, from the Greek.



Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.